Close this search box.

Best Squirrel Bait

best squirrel bait

There’s no denying that squirrels can be pesky little creatures. They seem to have a knack for getting into things they shouldn’t and can be hard to get rid of once they’ve established themselves in your home or garden. There are several different baits that you can use to trap them, so we’ll look at the options available and help you decide which is the best squirrel bait for you.

Our Top Rated Squirrel Bait
Ramik Squirrel Lure
Non-Toxic Squirrel Attractant
This is a safe, non-toxic product with no foul odor that uses only food-grade ingredients to attract squirrels. Ramik is allowing you to capture unwanted critters for easy removal from your property.

There are many types of bait products to catch squirrels available on the market, but three of them stood out as the best bait for sale.

If You’re Looking for the Best Squirrel Bait Products in 2024, Look No Further

Our #1 Rated
Ramik Lure for Squirrels Paste Bait by Neogen review
Ramik Lure for Squirrels Paste Bait by Neogen
  • Doesn’t dry out
  • Nontoxic formula
  • No foul odor

Check Price
People's Choice
Kaytee Squirrel and Critter Blend Bait review
Kaytee Squirrel and Critter Blend Bait
  • Safe and humane
  • Uses grains and seeds
  • Proven effectiveness

Check Price
NB Squirrel Bait by WCS
NB Squirrel Bait by WCS
  • Won’t dry out
  • Nonallergenic
  • No bad scent

Check Price

While having squirrels in your yard may not seem like a severe issue at first, the fact is squirrels can be a very problematic issue to have. Sure, they may seem small and harmless, but squirrels are not only a nuisance, but they can also carry serious diseases (such as the plague) that can harm you, your family, and your pets.

To make matters worse, squirrels are incredibly destructive. If they move into your attic or garage, they can cause significant damage to your property. Squirrels tend to chew on everything they see, which means you could face serious issues with them gnawing on electrical cords or other wiring in your home.

One of the best ways to get rid of squirrels around your yard is to catch them with cage traps. By catching squirrels, you’re able to keep them locked up until a pest control service, or your local exterminator can come out and retrieve them.

However, it’s not enough to correctly set a squirrel trap to lure the target animal. Squirrels are wily animals and can evade regular traps easily. So you need to give them a desirable and appealing bait to help coax them into your traps. You can use different kinds of bait to catch a squirrel.

Review of the Top 3 Best Squirrel Bait Products on the Market

You have several options available depending on how you would like to tackle your squirrel issue. In this article, we will review the best squirrel bait for trapping and keeping them alive. If you are looking for other methods for removing squirrels from your home or yard, you should check out our articles on squirrel poison or squirrel repellent.

Depending on how you would prefer to get rid of your squirrels, you have several choices on the bait you decide to use. There is no wrong or right way for getting rid of squirrels. And it’s important to remember that if you don’t eliminate them, they will destroy your property and expose you to severe diseases.

You can stop searching now if you’ve been on the hunt for the perfect product to remove your problematic squirrel issue. I’ve gathered the top 3 options and analyzed their critical benefits for convenience. Of the 3 best squirrel baits on the market right now, one impressed me as the most superior one available. I came to this conclusion based on how effective, reliable, and dependable it is. This undisputed winner is Ramik Lure for Squirrels.


1. Ramik Lure – Non-Toxic Attractant for Live Squirrel Traps (Editor’s Choice)

If you want to use a live trap to capture your squirrels, then you can be assured that even the pickiest rodents will be interested in Ramik Lure. It is a safe, non-toxic product that uses only food-grade ingredients to attract unwanted squirrels, allowing you to capture them for easy removal from your property.

How it Works

Squirrels can be finicky animals, especially if they have a wide selection of food in your yard. You want a product that is even more attractive than your garden or your home’s wiring to the squirrels.

Ramik Lure uses 100% food-safe ingredients that are proven to draw the squirrel in, encouraging it to pick the lure over other offerings. Combined with actual food products (like apple slices), it makes an irresistible squirrel trap bait.

Place Ramik Lure in the trap pan of the cage trap and enjoy catching squirrels.

In-Depth Review

Not all people understand how cautious some squirrels can be. While most products claim that they’ll catch the squirrel without hesitation, this product admits that it works best when used alongside fresh produce. This shows that the company understands how squirrels think and that Ramik Lure was created with that knowledge in mind.

Ramik Lure comes in a sturdy screw-top container, meaning you can take out exactly the portion you want. It uses small pellets to attract the squirrels—the remaining stay in the tub, out of the reach of air and other foraging animals. You can store the remaining unused portion in a dry place until needed.

Should You Use Ramik Lure?
This product is safe to use around children and pets, and you don’t need to use gloves to handle it. While it is unsafe to eat, you don’t have to panic if you accidentally touch it. It also means you can use it in and around your home, basement, garage, or attic without fear. All in all, this is the best squirrel bait for traps.
  • Completely safe to use
  • Sturdy packaging
  • Very attractive to squirrels
  • Nonlethal formula
  • May not work as well on its own

2. Kaytee Squirrel and Critter Blend – A Safe, Dependable and Non-Lethal Squirrel Bait

If you do not want to kill bothersome squirrels, Kaytee’s Squirrel and Critter Blend is exactly what you need to safely and gently coax critters into a squirrel trap for quick removal. It is a safe and harmless product and uses just a combination of corn, whole peanuts, grains, nuts, and seeds – a squirrel’s favorite foods – to help capture them.

Kaytee is the perfect mix for catching squirrels. And it can also be used as birdseed in your backyard bird feeder.

How it Works
Squirrels are foragers by nature and are always looking for an easy meal. Katyee’s gives them that by bribing them into your squirrel trap with their favorite treats. The squirrels are naturally attracted to these foods, which are part of their regular diet, and wander into traps to get at it.

In-Depth Review

Kaytee’s Squirrel and Critter Blend was initially designed to feed squirrels and keep them out of the bird feeder. This makes it an excellent bait for catching squirrels with a humane trap.

Kaytee comes in a heavy-duty woven plastic bag so it won’t split or tear. Furthermore, there is no bulky, wasteful packing involved. That makes storage a breeze when you’re not using it. The product consists of small bits of squirrel food, meaning it’s not toxic or dangerous. You don’t have to be worried about accidentally harming your children or pets when you use Kaytee.

What’s the Final Word on Kaytee?

You really can’t go wrong with Kaytee. With its sturdy packaging and non-toxic formula, this product has been shown to work and will help you eliminate your squirrels without worrying about harming them.

  • Proven to work
  • Uses nontoxic ingredients
  • Durable, minimalist packaging
  • Won’t harm any squirrels
  • Doesn’t actually kill squirrels
  • Package only comes in one size

3. WCS NB Paste – The Best Humane Squirrel Bait

We like to use peanut butter on our squirrel traps, but not everyone can handle peanuts due to allergies. Peanut butter also tends to dry out in a cage trap, which means the squirrels will ignore it. So if you’re looking for a highly effective and humane formula that works as well as peanut butter but won’t dry out or have dangerous allergens, you will be thrilled with WCS NB Paste.

How it Works

Squirrels love sunflower seeds, whole peanuts in the shell, and other nuts, and it’s easy for them to run up and stuff a bunch into their mouth and skitter off. Using a paste on a trap pan helps prevent that, but peanut butter can dry out, and somebody can’t handle it due to allergies. WCS NB Paste helps solve that problem by luring squirrels in without letting them run off before the cage trap closes.

In-Depth Review

This unique product uses a great idea (using peanut butter to catch squirrels) and improves upon it. Unlike other types of squirrel baits, which can risk allowing the squirrel to escape or kill them, this one is a safe and non-toxic formula. It is also more effective than peanut butter since it doesn’t dry out. Even better, it is a product that is aware of the risk of allergic reactions and avoids adding any peanut butter to this product.

This product comes in a convenient screw-top container, making removing the desired amount a breeze. Once satisfied with the amount you’ve removed, you can secure the lid back on the jar. That can help prolong the product’s shelf-life and make it harder for any animals to get into the packaging.

What Makes WCS NB Paste a Winner?
The best thing about this product is that it is safe and will not harm children or pets. You can decide how to eradicate squirrels and won’t accidentally stumble upon any rodent corpses in your humane squirrel trap. Because it works so well and is such a good product for cage traps, it gets the highest marks from me in this review.
  • Won’t dry out
  • Doesn’t kill squirrels
  • Nonallergenic (no peanuts)
  • Sturdy packaging
  • No bad scent
  • Only attracts, doesn’t kill
  • May contain other allergens

What is the Best Squirrel Bait in 2024? – Comprehensive Buyer’s Guide

Choosing the best squirrel baits for your infestation can be very stressful. After all, nobody wants to accidentally choose the wrong type of bait to catch a squirrel.

I understand how important it is to you to have trustworthy and reliable squirrel baits to help eliminate your squirrel problems. That is why I have taken the time to carefully review the best and most potent squirrel baits available for you.

In this buyer’s guide, I will analyze all aspects of these squirrel baits to help you make an educated and informed decision that you can feel good about.

Do These Squirrel Baits Work?

When looking for the best squirrel bait option, there are two main things two consider. First, is the bait going to attract the squirrel(s)? No matter which method you choose (trapping, poisoning, or repelling), the only way to eradicate the squirrel issue is by ensuring the product attracts the squirrel(s). Second, once the product attracts the culprit, you need to ensure that the job you are looking to do is done efficiently and effectively. In this case, the bait you choose should attract the squirrel and hold it long enough to trap it.

How can you know you’re choosing the best product?

Here’s what I’ve focused on in this review:

  • Each product that I have reviewed is proven to work.
  • The baits use proven attractants to lure in the squirrels.

  • Critters will be drawn to the squirrel trap and won’t ignore it.
  • You can then decide what you want to do with your captured squirrel.

Your satisfaction with your baits to catch squirrels is very important, which is why I’ve chosen these products for review.

What is the Fate of the Squirrel?

Another huge consideration is if the squirrel bait product is going to kill or harm the squirrel or if it can be used in a live trap. In this guide, I have only highlighted baits that are used to trap the squirrel. Once the squirrel is trapped, you can remove it yourself or call a local wildlife expert to ensure that it is removed humanely and properly.

There are four important questions to ask yourself when choosing lethal or non-lethal bait to trap squirrels.

  1. Will the squirrel die after eating the proper bait?
  2. If it dies, will it suffer, or will it be merciful?
  3. Will I have to deal with a sick or dying squirrel myself?
  4. Does the squirrel know if the bait is toxic or not?

These products do not prolong the suffering of the squirrel, so you can feel good about buying them. Regardless of what’s in them, they will draw these pesky neighbors into the squirrel trap for capture.

What Ingredients are Used in These Squirrel Bait Products?

These baits use ingredients that are both attractive and tasty to squirrels, such as:

  • Nuts
  • Seeds

  • Grains
  • Flavorings

In addition to these natural ingredients, some also contain toxic ingredients (such as anti-coagulants) which will kill the squirrel. The product you choose will determine the outcome for the squirrel.

What Form Does the Bait Come In?

Finally, you want to know exactly what you’re getting when choosing your best squirrel bait product. This information will help you make the right choice.

These squirrel baits come in many different shapes and styles, including:

  • Granules
  • Bars

  • Pastes
  • Natural

Each has its benefits and advantages for use, giving you a variety of options to choose from. I’ve gone through each right bait to ensure that you know what form it will come in, so you can be certain that the one you pick is correct for your squirrel trap.

Conclusion: Getting Rid of Squirrels from Your Property

Squirrels on your property are neither cute nor safe. They can quickly put your home, garden, and even family and pets in danger with their presence. So when you have a squirrel problem, you don’t want to mess around with messy and useless baits that don’t work.

No matter the scope of your squirrel infestation, you’ll want the best bait to catch squirrels that works. I’ve chosen products across various formats, ranging from non-toxic pastes to fast-acting and lethal poison baits. Depending on what you’re looking for, you can be assured you will choose the right squirrel trap bait when you pick one of these.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for dependable squirrel bait, you’ll find something that works well for you here. You can’t go wrong with the Ramik Lure for Squirrels because it’s safe, reliable, and proven to work. However, any products covered in this review will yield the needed results.

Before you know it, your squirrel problems will be a distant memory, allowing you to enjoy your home without their unwanted presence!